As a writer, it’s freeing to learn that the natural habit of the human mind is to think metaphorically. Lately I have ‘encountered’ many quotations on this subject from two men I would never have put in the same ‘boat’. Let me call them Norrie and Dan, since I’ve been ‘spending’ a lot of time in their ‘company’. Frankly, I am sick of fruitless debates over subjects such as the literal account of ‘Creation’ and whether ‘God’ exists.
You might as well question whether we need words. Here are some quotations which ‘nail down’ answers to the wobbly question of what a metaphor is. Of course the quotes are taken out of context, but they are exact. Take your pick:
- My own view is that every form of speech can be reduced to metaphor, but metaphor is primary language, and metaphor cannot be reduced to another kind of language: as long as we use words at all we can never escape metaphors, but only change them.
- Our primary thinking…is not rational but metaphorical, an identifying of subjective and objective worlds in huge mental pictures.
- Metaphors are statements of identity: they tell us, for instance, that the poet and the lady he loves are shadow and sun.
- Metaphor does not evoke a world of things linked together by overstated analogies; it evokes a world of swirling currents of energy that run back and forth between subject and object.
- (Metaphor) is also a primary structural effort of consciousness. (It) may be followed by or even translated into more continuous rational thinking.
From The Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown:
- Those who truly understand their faiths understand the stories are metaphorical.
- Every faith in the world is based on fabrication. That is the definition of faith — acceptance of that which we imagine to be true, that which we cannot prove. Every religion describes God through metaphor, allegory, and exaggeration from the early Egyptians to modern Sunday School.
- Metaphors are a way to help our minds process the unprocessable. The problems arise when we begin to believe literally in our own metaphors.
- By teaching through a metaphorical game (Tarot cards), the followers of the Grail disguised their message from the watchful eyes of the Church.
- Magdalene’s story has been shouted from the rooftops for centuries in all kinds of metaphors and languages. Her story is everywhere once you open your eyes.
For an example of a practical application of this wisdom Frye says, “The account of creation in the Bible does not describe the origin of nature and was probably never intended to. If it were, it would have been a little cleverer and not had the trees created the day before the sun was.”
Thank you for spending some of your time reading this post. Please browse around top and bottom and, if you like, write comments.